Four finalists are in line to run Middleborough. The bar the McGrail-Germain administration left behind is low. The one residents have set is high, and it applies to the Select Board, too.
Middleborough — Congratulations are in order. Out of a field of more than 20 applicants, four people are now finalists to become Middleborough’s next permanent town manager: Shawn Cadime, Anthony Delmonaco, Timothy McInerney and Matthew Wojcik.
Making the final four in a search like this is no small thing, and each of them deserves the town’s thanks for wanting the job. They should also know what they would be walking into.
The finalists
The bar they inherit
Here is the good news for whoever gets the job: the bar left by the McGrail-Germain administration, former Town Manager Jay McGrail and former Select Board Chair Mark Germain, is low.
That administration put a budget book in the hands of Joe Perkins, the first interim town manager, and McGrail left for Harwich soon after. The town’s interim leadership has since said that book was not accurate. In March, at a joint meeting of the Select Board, Finance Committee and School Committee, this author told Perkins the book was his now and should be reviewed. He dutifully did, and found a $3.3 million structural deficit it did not show. Two years of polite, professional questions about the town’s finances had mostly been ignored. Worse, some were met with attempts to silence them. A $3.3 million hole does not open overnight, and those warnings were on the record. Who knew it was there before the book changed hands, and when did they know it? The town deserves a straight answer.
At the Nov. 9 Town Meeting, Interim Town Manager Bob Nunes, a former director of the state Division of Local Services, put it plainly: “The balance sheets are a mess.” At an earlier Select Board meeting, he said the town’s cash had not been reconciled for the past three years, leaving an unexplained gap of $1.2 million. Of fiscal 2026, he said only: “It’s going to be a big number.” The town is still waiting to learn how big. Because the books were not in order, free cash and retained earnings could not be certified in time for the Nov. 9 Town Meeting, and the town had to draw on stabilization funds to pay for warrant articles. Residents would be hard-pressed to remember the last time that happened here. The Finance Committee has already approved a letter recommending a forensic audit of the town’s books, and Select Board Chair Teresa Farley is 100 percent behind it. Watch anyone who tries to walk the town back from that position. That includes anyone who asks for residents’ votes next spring, and anyone already on the record voting against transparency.
Other questions are still open. Middleborough bought two Tahoes for $110,644 in 2024, one for McGrail’s use as town manager and one that Peck drives. The town has not said what money paid for them, or whether snow-and-ice funds were involved, and no vote authorizing the purchase appears in the record. A roughly $1 million public works turnback that McGrail and Peck defended before Germain’s board last fall has never been audited. Finance Director Susan Nickerson left in October, in close proximity to more questions about the town’s finances, tied to the troubling findings laid out by Perkins, by Nunes and by CBIZ, the town’s auditor, which has the town bracing for control deficiencies and material weaknesses. Public Works Director Christopher Peck, after being asked to answer written questions about the water deals, gave notice Nov. 4 and is reportedly headed to Harwich to join McGrail. Neither has said publicly why they left when they did. The questions they leave behind still need answers.
Germain’s half is on the record, too. He led the board that was supposed to oversee the manager. He signed the October 2023 draft of the Carver water agreement and, like the rest of the board, never signed the final version. And under Germain, the board let residents be insulted at public meetings.
We have seen none of that from the Perkins-Farley and Nunes-Farley administrations. Nunes came back, promised a closer look and has kept at it. Both interims, alongside Farley, have been honest with residents about what they found. On professionalism and decorum alone, the next town manager walks into a better environment than the last one did. But issues still lurk around some corners.
The bar the people set
The real bar was set by the people of Middleborough, and they set it high. They set it in April, when voters resoundingly rejected Germain’s bid to stay on the Select Board. They raised it again on Nov. 9, when Town Meeting turned down Article 19 because residents asked for the details and didn’t get them.
Those details were Brian Giovanoni’s to deliver. In August, the board handed him the Carver water deal. He recommended a placeholder, and Town Meeting never saw an agreement. That is what makes it hard to understand. Giovanoni does water work for a living. He knows what an agreement like this needs: rates, volumes, metering, a term, and who owns the pipe. None of it reached the floor. Why not? He owes the town that answer, and residents should hold him to it.
Residents are reading the warrant, reading the budget and showing up. None of what they expect from the next town manager is negotiable.
What Middleborough expects
To the Select Board
Finalist interviews are approaching. Before the board asks a single candidate about transparency, ethics or following the rules, it owes the town answers of its own.
Start with the Carver water agreement. In October, the town said it could not locate a fully executed copy. The version in the town’s Document Center is a draft, signed by three Middleborough members with its edits still pending. The final version carries no Middleborough signature at all. Giovanoni made the 2023 motion to approve and sign the deal, and his line is blank on both.
Questions the town still hasn’t answered
- Middleborough began pumping water to Carver on June 23, 2022, and the first invoice on file starts Dec. 1, 2023. Did the town charge Carver for those 526 days? How much? Where are the receipts? Let’s see the treasury reports. They belong on the list for a scoped forensic audit.
- Which version of the 2023 Carver agreement governs?
- Why did the member who moved to sign it leave his own line blank, and did he recuse himself at any point?
- Did KP Law have written informed consent to represent both towns on the same deal?
- What covers Carver’s water now that the Town Meeting extension ran out Oct. 30?
This story will not go away until the town gets the answers it deserves. Answer the people’s questions first. Then ask yours.
And act appropriately
Answers are half the job. The other half is how board members carry themselves.
To Brian Giovanoni: Stop referring to people as terrorists. Stop telling stories the record doesn’t support. That kind of talk is how officials end up in court in their personal capacity, not just their official one.
To Thomas White: Stop lecturing young people who come to Town Meeting. What happened at the Fall Town Meeting was inappropriate, and it was disgusting to watch. They are doing exactly what this town needs more of. Welcome them.
The town has seen enough. Voters set the standard in April, and they will measure every board member against it. Conduct yourselves accordingly.
So long as The G.O.A.T. is here, residents will have the records and the reporting they need to hold their officials to account.
A word to whoever gets the job
The title “reporter” is not a subpoena, though a reporter who isn’t truthful can end up on the receiving end of one. Answer every public records request, fully and on time; the law requires it. Nothing requires you to sit for an interview with someone whose work doesn’t square with the public record. Put your answers in writing, post the documents and let the record speak. It doesn’t misquote anyone.
To Shawn Cadime, Anthony Delmonaco, Timothy McInerney and Matthew Wojcik: congratulations again. The people have raised the bar. Meet it, and you will find a town ready to work with you.
John A. Barrella III is an elected member of the Middleborough Finance Committee and serves on the Town Manager Search Committee. The views expressed here are his own and are not those of either the Finance Committee or the Town Manager Search Committee.






Leave a Reply