Card reading: Nine items became six. The clock is running. A narrowed records request on Middleborough’s water, dated Nov. 16. Under state law, Carver has 10 business days to respond in writing.

Carver asked for help narrowing a records request. It got a tighter one, and the clock is running.

Carver · Public Records

The new request cuts nine items to six, names who and what to search, and asks Carver to say in writing if no bill or payment exists for Middleborough’s water. State law gives the Town 10 business days to answer.

C The Town of Carver asked for help narrowing a public records request about the water it buys from Middleborough. It now has a narrower one, and a deadline.

The new request, dated Nov. 16 and filed by John Barrella, who owns and publishes The G.O.A.T. News, replaces the nine items he sought on Oct. 28 with six. It answers each point in the Town’s response, renews the request for a fee waiver, and asks a question Carver’s own files should be able to settle: what Carver was billed, and what it paid, for water from Middleborough beginning June 23, 2022.

“Where no such record exists, a written statement to that effect is itself responsive.”

That sentence, from the letter, is the point of the narrowing. Either Carver produces invoices and payment records for the period, or it says in writing, item by item, that it has none and identifies the files and systems it searched. The letter asks the Town to say so expressly for any stretch after June 23, 2022 with no invoice from, or payment to, Middleborough. Either answer would close a question The G.O.A.T. has been reporting since October.

What was cut, and what was kept

Carver’s response, reported here Nov. 11, priced the original request at 10.5 hours of staff time and $262.50, declined a full fee waiver, said the Town holds no metering records, and asked that the correspondence item be narrowed with names, search terms and dates.

Carver asked for help narrowing one item. The new letter tightens the whole request. It drops three items: board votes and minutes, which the Town says are already on its website; metering records, which the Town says it does not keep; and audit records. It keeps the money trail: invoices Carver received from Middleborough, payments it made, the water agreement as Carver holds it, the district’s customer billing totals, and the district’s annual reports to the state Department of Environmental Protection.

It also cuts the work. A vendor payment history from Carver’s accounting system, with the warrant page approving each payment, satisfies the payments item. Summary reports satisfy the billing item, and customer names and account information may be left out. Paper is to be scanned only where no electronic copy exists, and records may be produced as each item is ready, invoices and payments first.

On correspondence, the letter supplies what the Town asked for. It names the offices whose mail is to be searched: the Town’s chief administrative officer, the Select Board, the Planning Board and its chair, the Capital Planning Committee, the Town Accountant, the Treasurer/Collector, and the district’s commissioners, superintendent and clerk. It limits the search to mail exchanged with Middleborough town addresses, to eight terms (invoice, bill, payment, meter, interconnection, intermunicipal, IMA and manganese) and to the 19 months from June 2022 through December 2023. Carver’s letter had said the Town is “willing to work with you” to narrow that item.

Nine items became six

The Oct. 28 request, Carver’s estimate for each item, and what the Nov. 16 letter does with it

Oct. 28 itemCarver’s estimateNov. 16 request
Agreements2.0 hrsKeptItem 3, as Carver holds it, signed or unsigned
Votes and minutesOnline, $0Dropped
Metering records“Does not maintain”DroppedSee billing totals, Item 4
Invoices from Middleborough0.5 hrsKeptItem 1
Payments to Middleborough2.0 hrsKeptItem 2; a system report satisfies it
Customer billing totals1.5 hrsKeptItem 4; summary reports, through Jan. 2025
Reports to the state0.5 hrsKeptItem 5; DEP annual reports, 2022–2025
CorrespondencePendingNarrowedItem 6; named offices, 8 terms, 19 months
Audit records1.0 hrsDropped
Scanning paper3.0 hrsNarrowedPaper-only records only
Total10.5 hrs, $262.50Revised estimate requested; waiver renewed

Source: Town of Carver response to the Oct. 28, 2026 request; narrowed request dated Nov. 16, 2026.

Carver is on the clock

Under the state public records law, a records access officer must respond in writing within 10 business days of receiving a request. If the records cannot be produced in that time, the response must say when they will be, and a town’s timeline is capped at 25 business days after it first receives the request. Going past that takes a petition to the state Supervisor of Records, who can grant a single extension of no more than 30 business days for good cause.

A town that does not respond within 10 business days may not charge a fee for the records at all. If it does respond on time, the state’s regulations let it hold the records until any fee is paid. The clock on the narrowed request runs from the day Carver receives it.

The clock

What the public records law requires of Carver once it receives the narrowed request

10business days to respond in writingG.L. c. 66, § 10(b)
25business days: the longest production timeline a town may set on its own, from first receiptG.L. c. 66, § 10(b)(vi)
+30business days: the most the Supervisor of Records can add, on a petition showing good causeG.L. c. 66, § 10(c)
$0the fee a town may charge if it misses the 10-day responseG.L. c. 66, § 10(e)

Records may be held until any fee is paid, under 950 CMR 32.06(2)(f).

The fee, again

Carver set its estimate at $25 an hour, the statutory maximum, rather than at its employees’ higher pay, and noted that as a town of fewer than 20,000 residents it is not required to provide the first two hours free. It acknowledged the public interest in the subject but declined a full waiver, pointing to the size of the request, the staff time and the cost.

The new letter asks again. State law lets a records officer waive or reduce a fee when disclosure is in the public interest because it is likely to contribute significantly to public understanding of government, and is not primarily in the requester’s commercial interest. The letter notes that the Town has already acknowledged the public interest, and says the narrowing answers each ground the Town gave. If the Town will not waive the fee, the letter asks it to reduce it and to put its reasons in writing. It commits to paying promptly any fee assessed after the Town decides, and reserves the right to appeal to the Supervisor of Records.

What the record already shows

Middleborough water began flowing to North Carver on June 23, 2022, when the district “shut off its water plant and activated the Middleborough interconnection,” according to the notice posted on Carver’s website. The district’s 2022 water quality report says Middleborough supplied its customers from June 24 through the end of that year.

Middleborough’s side of the ledger is public. The G.O.A.T. reviewed all 21 invoices Middleborough sent Carver and Bridgewater and found every one correct to the penny. Middleborough’s billing file for Carver begins with a period starting Dec. 1, 2023.

An invoice that adds up is not the same as a payment received. Whether each Carver payment reached Middleborough, and where it was recorded, is a question for the treasury side of the books: the treasurer’s receipts and the reports of the water enterprise fund, which accounts for the town’s water revenue. Set beside Carver’s own payment records, Item 2 of the narrowed request, those reports would confirm that every dollar billed was received and booked where it belongs, or show where a payment is missing, was booked somewhere else, or does not match.

That check carries extra weight in Middleborough. The town stopped reconciling its bank statements against its own books in fiscal 2023 and has yet to account for $1.2 million in cash variances across fiscal 2023 through 2025, as The G.O.A.T. reported Nov. 4. Nothing in the public record ties those variances to water payments. Matching the two towns’ records is how that gets confirmed or ruled out.

Carver’s own notices fill in what happened between June 2022 and December 2023. The district’s commissioners told customers they expected to switch back from Middleborough water to the district’s own wells on June 1, 2023. A manganese advisory the district issued that summer reported samples of its own treated water taken June 5 and June 8. On Dec. 1, 2023, the district reconnected to Middleborough’s supply, the first day Middleborough’s billing file covers.

That record refines The G.O.A.T.’s Nov. 7 count of 556 days with no invoice. If the switch went as announced, the district was on its own wells for about six months of that stretch. The open question narrows to roughly 11 months of Middleborough water, from June 23, 2022 to about June 1, 2023, plus the 30 days in March 2024 that Middleborough’s file does not cover. The narrowed request is written to answer it from Carver’s side.

The water and the invoices

Where North Carver’s water came from, and which stretches Middleborough’s billing file covers, June 2022 to June 2026

June 2022Dec. 2023June 2026
  • Middleborough water with no invoice in Middleborough’s file: June 23, 2022 to about June 1, 2023, and March 2024
  • District’s own wells: switch-back announced for June 1, 2023; reconnected Dec. 1, 2023
  • Middleborough water invoiced by Middleborough, Dec. 1, 2023 through June 2026

Sources: North Carver Water District notices and 2022 water quality report on the Town of Carver website; Middleborough billing records as reported Nov. 7.

Why it matters

Middleborough Town Meeting rejected Article 19 on Nov. 9. As amended, it would have let the Select Board sell water to Carver. Water sold from one town to another is public business on both sides of the line. If Middleborough water went unbilled, Middleborough’s ratepayers carried the cost. If it was billed and paid, Carver’s records will show it.

The narrowed request asks the Town to search the district’s records too. Chapter 152 of the Acts of 2026, approved July 31, dissolved the North Carver Water District and required its commissioners to turn the district’s files over to Carver’s Select Board.

Either way, a complete answer closes the question: the records if they exist, a written statement if they do not.

Carver residents meet next at a Special Town Meeting on Dec. 1 at 6:30 p.m. in the Carver Middle High School auditorium, where they can put questions to town officials in public.

The water and the paper

How the North Carver arrangement reached a records request

The G.O.A.T. stands for Government Oversight, Accountability & Transparency. Records requests like this one are how that work gets done.

Anyone with records on Carver’s water purchases can send them to john@thegoatnewsinmiddleborough.com. The G.O.A.T. protects its sources.

Barrella filed the records request described in this story. He serves on the Middleborough Finance Committee, which took up the town’s water agreements before Town Meeting, and on the Town Manager Search Committee. This article does not speak for either body.

Leave a Reply

Latest Updates

Middleborough’s neighborhood newsroom

Get the Daily Newsletter

Independent local reporting, clear facts, and the stories your neighbors are talking about.