In Carver, the board that polices sand mining is stocked with the industry it regulates

By John Barrella

Correction: An earlier version of this story reported that Alan Germain was appointed to the Carver Earth Removal Committee in 2023 to fill its trucking-industry seat. Germain has not served on the Earth Removal Committee and does not hold that seat, according to the Carver town clerk’s office. The G.O.A.T. News regrets the error.

CARVER — When the town’s Earth Removal Committee gavels in Tuesday afternoon for a routine agenda — a requested delay on one sand-and-gravel matter, a look back at a site visit on another — it will do so as a body whose own composition has drawn years of conflict-of-interest complaints and, more recently, brushed up against a federal lawsuit.

The committee, which the town bylaw sets at seven members, meets at 3 p.m. in Room 4 of Town Hall and is the local gatekeeper for one of Southeastern Massachusetts’ most lucrative and contested industries: the removal of sand and gravel from the sandy soils of the Plymouth-Carver region, often stripped from land as cranberry growers reshape or expand their bogs.

Critics have long argued that the mining is dressed up as agriculture to sidestep permits, draining an aquifer that supplies drinking water to more than 100,000 people. In August, the Conservation Law Foundation sued one of the region’s largest operators, A.D. Makepeace, in federal court, alleging years of unlawful wetlands destruction from sand mining at sites including two in Carver.

https://www.clf.org/newsroom/ma-cranberry-grower-and-sand-miner-damaging-wetlands-and-waterways

A.D. Makepeace’s proposed expansion, 59 Federal Road, Carver, MA.

By the town’s own bylaw, the committee that regulates that activity is built, in part, from the industry it oversees. Chapter 136 of Carver’s general bylaws sets the panel at seven members: three representatives of the Select Board, two nominated by the Cape Cod Cranberry Growers’ Association, one nominated by the Board of Health, and — at Section 136-3B(1)(d) — “one member of the trucking industry, nominated by the ERC.”

That last clause is the unusual one. The committee that permits sand and gravel hauling selects the hauler who sits on it, and forwards that name for appointment. In practice, the panel has been led and staffed for years by people who grow cranberries, mine sand, or haul it.

Tuesday’s agenda

The immediate business on Tuesday is modest. The committee is scheduled to take up a continued public hearing for applicant Derek Maksy, tied to a parcel listed as 0 Wareham Street (Map 126, Lot 13-0); according to the agenda, Maksy is asking that the matter be pushed to the committee’s October meeting. Members are also set to review an Aug. 29 site visit connected to Permit 24-01 at 104 Tremont Street, hear a report from the committee’s agent, and handle routine bills.

The agenda also notes, as Carver committee agendas do, that the public-access station Area 58 will record the meeting and asks any other person recording to state their name for the record.

A committee of insiders

The committee’s chair, Scott Hannula, is himself a cranberry grower and longtime figure in the sand and trucking business; public filings identify him as an officer of two family cranberry companies that own bogs in Carver, and his firms have held earth-removal permits from the very committee he now leads. He was named chair in 2023 as an “industry representative.” His predecessor as chair, who led the committee for roughly three decades until 2022, ran a cranberry company that mined sand from its own land during his tenure.

Who occupies the trucking seat is not easy to establish from the town’s own records. Carver’s published Earth Removal Committee roster lists Michael C. Harrison, Patricia Killeen, Roger Shores Jr., Steve Ward and Michael Wainio, along with agent Robert Pike, and leaves the name of the industry representative — the seat the chair holds — blank. The same page describes that seat as one for “an earth removal contractor or construction industry person,” language that does not appear in the bylaw the committee operates under.

The committee’s most recent predecessor in that seat is a matter of record. Hannula first appears in the committee’s attendance rolls at its Aug. 30, 2023 meeting, the same month he was appointed as the panel’s industry representative.

None of these arrangements is necessarily unlawful. Massachusetts municipalities frequently seat industry members on technical boards, and the state’s conflict-of-interest law, G.L. c. 268A, generally turns not on membership itself but on whether an official participates in specific matters affecting their own financial interests, and whether they properly disclose and step aside. Committee minutes show members do at times recuse themselves from site visits involving companies they are connected to.

Ethics complaints and a federal suit

The industry makeup of the committee has drawn formal challenges. The Community Land & Water Coalition, an environmental group co-founded by attorney Margaret “Meg” Sheehan, has for years pressed the town over what it describes as conflicts of interest on the committee.

Among the defendants is Alan Germain, who owns and operates Alan Germain Trucking and has held a series of prominent civic posts in Carver. Sheehan filed the federal civil-rights and defamation suit in September 2024 in U.S. District Court in Boston, naming the towns of Carver and Plymouth, several local officials, and two sand-mining companies. The suit alleges, broadly, that the defendants worked to silence her advocacy against sand mining in the region. In a May 2025 ruling, U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs dismissed a number of Sheehan’s claims but allowed others to proceed, including claims against Germain; in a March 2026 ruling, the judge denied an effort by two of the corporate defendants to dismiss additional claims under the state’s anti-SLAPP law. The defendants have denied Sheehan’s allegations, and the case remains pending.

Residents have separately said that investigators from the Massachusetts Office of the Inspector General visited Carver Town Hall in March 2023 seeking records related to earth-removal permitting. The Inspector General’s office, asked previously about an inquiry, has declined to comment.

The stakes

Behind the procedural agenda items lies a resource question that has animated Carver politics for years. By one accounting presented to the committee, more than 30 million cubic yards of earth have been removed from Carver over the past two decades, with more than 1,000 acres disturbed, deforested, or stripped — activity that residents in the Great Meadow area of South Carver have linked to private wells running dry.

The committee has generally declined to take dramatic enforcement action, and its defenders note that it collects per-cubic-yard fees that fund road repair and staff, and that it operates within a bylaw and a state regulatory framework that treat much bog-related excavation as agricultural.


Reporting note: This article is based on the Earth Removal Committee’s posted agenda, Town of Carver records and meeting minutes, federal court filings in Sheehan v. Town of Carver et al. (D. Mass. No. 24-cv-12347), Massachusetts Department of Transportation carrier records, and a Conservation Law Foundation announcement of its Clean Water Act suit against A.D. Makepeace. The lawsuit claims described here are unproven and the defendants deny them. Committee membership rotates; readers seeking a member’s current status should consult the town’s appointed-committee listings.

Leave a Reply

Latest Updates

Middleborough’s neighborhood newsroom

Get the Daily Newsletter

Independent local reporting, clear facts, and the stories your neighbors are talking about.