Middleborough balanced its budget on layoffs. Its last audited books stop at 2024.

Nineteen jobs went to fill a $3.5 million gap. Fiscal 2025 is still unaudited, and the deadlines for free cash and the tax rate are here.

By John Barrella

MIDDLEBOROUGH — More than 14 months after the fiscal year closed, the town still does not have an audit of its fiscal 2025 finances. The work remains unfinished at CBIZ, the firm performing it.

The delay is not a paperwork problem confined to Town Hall. An unfinished audit sits upstream of two state processes that determine whether Middleborough has any money left over from last year to spend, and when property tax bills reach households this fall.

Both processes depend on the same underlying condition: books that are closed and cash that reconciles.

What is missing

Fiscal 2025 ended June 30, 2025. The town’s website posts audited financial statements for fiscal 2021 through fiscal 2024. There is no fiscal 2025 package.

The most recent audit on file, covering the year that ended June 30, 2024, was performed by Hague, Sahady & Co. of Fall River, and the independent auditor’s report is dated July 22, 2025 — roughly 13 months after the close of that fiscal year.

The fiscal 2025 work is with CBIZ, a national firm that is itself in transition. Grant Thornton Advisors announced on July 29 that it will acquire CBIZ in a $5 billion transaction expected to close in the fourth quarter of this year.

Municipal audit work in Massachusetts has consolidated sharply in recent years, leaving fewer firms to handle the same number of cities, towns and districts.

How the town changed auditors

Hague, Sahady & Co. had audited Middleborough’s books for years, and McGrail had praised the firm’s work in public. At a joint meeting of the Select Board and the Finance Committee, he spoke favorably of the auditors in front of both boards.

In the spring of 2025, the town put auditor services out to bid, and the firm submitted a proposal, received April 15, 2025.

It was rejected. In a letter dated June 24, 2025, McGrail told the firm that one minimum requirement in the request for proposals “was not met by the information included in the proposal”:

“The firm shall have audited at least ten (10) Massachusetts municipalities each year over the past three (3) years.”

“As such, your submission does not meet the Minimum Requirements set forth in the RFP and must be rejected,” the letter states. Missing that threshold is what made the bid “non-responsive,” the procurement term for a proposal that fails a stated minimum, which under state rules must then be rejected regardless of its merits.

Official letter from the Town of Middleborough, Massachusetts, dated June 24, 2025, regarding the rejection of a proposal for auditor services submitted by Hague, Sahady & Co.

Nothing in the letter concerns the quality of the firm’s work. The rejection turns entirely on the ten-municipality threshold.

The disqualification did not end that work, either. Hague Sahady’s audit of fiscal 2024, the most recent one Middleborough has, is dated July 22, 2025, a month after the rejection letter. The fiscal 2025 engagement went to CBIZ under the three-year contract that resulted from the RFP.

The letter answers one question and raises others. It was signed by the town manager, not the Select Board. It does not say who wrote the minimum requirement that disqualified the incumbent, a threshold of 10 Massachusetts municipal audits a year that would exclude many smaller regional firms, nor whether that requirement appeared in the town’s previous solicitations for the same work.

Who held the offices

Fiscal 2025 ran from July 1, 2024, to June 30, 2025. For the whole of it, Jay McGrail was town manager and Mark Germain chaired the Select Board.

The Select Board voted unanimously on Oct. 11, 2022, to select McGrail as town manager, succeeding Robert G. Nunes, and authorized two of its members to negotiate his contract, according to the minutes of that meeting.

At a Select Board meeting on Jan. 20, 2026, according to the minutes, McGrail said he had accepted a position with the town of Harwich and asked to be released from his resignation contract, committing to complete the fiscal 2027 budget and to provide free consulting services, using vacation time, with March 4 as his last day of employment.

The board voted unanimously to accept the resignation on those terms. Joseph Perkins, the town’s retired police chief, served as interim town manager after his departure.

Germain, who was chair for most of his two terms on the board, lost his seat to Tracie Craig-McGee in the annual town election on April 4, 2026 according to the town clerk’s official results.

The town’s fiscal 2024 audit, the most recent one completed, was issued during McGrail’s tenure, on July 22, 2025. The Select Board is scheduled to vote Monday on a contract making Nunes interim town manager.

Why it matters to free cash

The surplus a community carries out of a fiscal year is known as free cash: unspent appropriations, revenue collected above estimate, and unused free cash from the prior year. Towns rely on it at fall town meetings for one-time and capital spending.

No community may appropriate a dollar of it until the state’s director of accounts certifies an amount. Certification requires a town to close its books and reconcile its cash across three sets of records — the treasurer’s cash book, the bank statements, and the accountant’s general ledger — and to file a June 30 balance sheet with the Department of Revenue’s Division of Local Services.

Under the division’s year-end instructions, that balance sheet, along with a treasurer’s year-end cash report and a statement of indebtedness, was due Sept. 30. Schedule A, the annual financial report every city and town files with the state, is due Nov. 30. State guidelines say that if a community fails to file Schedule A by that date, the Department of Revenue is authorized to withhold the community’s local aid.

A completed audit is not itself a legal precondition for certification. But an audit and a year-end close draw on the same reconciliations, and the division identifies unreconciled cash, deficits in other funds, and inconsistent year-end forms as the most common reasons a certification is delayed or reduced. A town that cannot satisfy its auditor on those points generally cannot satisfy the Bureau of Accounts either.

The practical effect is that without a certified figure, Town Meeting cannot appropriate free cash in October, and no amount can be applied to reduce the tax rate.

There may be nothing left over

A certification is also not a guarantee of money.

The state’s calculation begins with a town’s year-end fund balance and subtracts what the books show is unavailable: deficits in other funds such as grants, revolving accounts and capital projects; property taxes committed but not collected; and negative deferred revenue, which arises when a community raises more for abatements than its history supports.

Those deductions are not small. The division reported that statewide, free cash certified as of June 30, 2025, would have been roughly $583 million higher without them. A town’s figure can come back lower than expected, at zero, or below it.

A shortfall does not disappear at the end of the year, either.

Under state law, an appropriation deficit — spending beyond what Town Meeting authorized — must be raised on the following year’s tax recap, and so must a revenue deficit, the gap when actual receipts fall short of what the town estimated. Either becomes a charge against next year’s tax rate.

That is what makes the audit consequential twice over. Its findings bear on whether there is a surplus to spend in October, and on what the town has to make up in the year after that.

What the interim manager found

Middleborough has already had one look at its own numbers this year, and it did not go well.

At a Select Board meeting on March 16, Joseph Perkins, then the interim town manager, told the board he did not trust the budget he had inherited. “I am not comfortable with the budget as presented,” he said. “I believe it is out of balance and I believe it’s out of balance significantly and there is a deficit.”

Perkins put the shortfall at roughly $3.3 million and questioned the estimate of local receipts he found in the budget, which he pegged at about $11.5 million against the $13 million the previous administration had projected. “Right now because of all the development we have, yes, we are in a very fertile time, but that will end,” he said. “That’s why you don’t overestimate, you stay conservative.”

“You don’t base a budget on dreams, wishes and unicorns,” he told the board. “You build it on numbers.”

The annual Town Meeting had to be pushed back to June 1. By the time a budget was ready, 19 employees were laid off, and more than 20 positions in all were cut or left unfilled once retirements, a resignation and vacancies were counted. The shortfall had grown to $3.5 million.

“I want people to understand the gravity of the situation,” Perkins told the Select Board when he presented the cuts on May 4. “This is a life event, and not a good one for employees.”

None of that was the product of an audit. It was a review of a budget in progress, done without the completed fiscal 2025 statements that would show where the town actually stood at the start of the year.

A forensic review has been requested

The Finance Committee has already voted to seek a closer examination of the town’s books. The committee approved and sent the Select Board a letter recommending a scoped forensic audit, along with a list of items it wants examined.

(The author is a member of the Finance Committee, and made and voted ‘yea’ the motion for the letter to be sent to the Selectboard.)

The second deadline

Setting a property tax rate requires a sequence of approvals, each waiting on the one before it. Assessors submit total valuations and new growth figures to the state’s Bureau of Local Assessment. The values are certified. The Select Board holds a public classification hearing and votes how to allocate the levy between residential and commercial property. The town files a tax rate recapitulation sheet, the recap, listing every appropriation and revenue source for the year. The Department of Revenue approves it, after which assessors may commit the taxes and the collector may issue bills.

The division publishes target dates for that sequence in Bulletin 2019-02. For communities that issue one actual bill in the fall, the recap is due Sept. 1 and bills are to be mailed by Sept. 30, with the first payment due Nov. 1. For communities that issue preliminary bills first, the recap is due Nov. 15 and actual bills are to be mailed by Dec. 31.

Middleborough’s published taxpayer information describes a bill issued in late September or early October and due Nov. 1, with a second bill due May 1 — the earlier schedule. The same guidance describes the town’s fallback when a rate is not set in time: an estimated bill, with the actual bill issued later in the year.

The bulletin states that the division will make every effort to accommodate communities but “cannot guarantee that communities submitting key data after these target dates will receive final certification or have the tax rate set in sufficient time to mail their actual tax bills on time.”

What a delay would cost

When bills are issued late, state law shifts the payment date to 30 days after mailing. For communities on the preliminary system that miss Dec. 31, the full remaining balance becomes due May 1 or 30 days after mailing, whichever is later, eliminating an installment budgeted for February. Interest on unpaid amounts accrues at 14 percent a year from the due date.

Estimated bills also move the window in which a property owner may seek an abatement, and they complicate escrow calculations and closings timed around a known bill.

For the town, the division warns that a late rate raises the risk of a cash flow shortfall requiring short-term borrowing, and it names two costs: the expense of a revenue anticipation note and the investment income forgone on collections not yet received.

Sources

John Barrella, who owns and operates The G.O.A.T. News, serves on the Middleborough Town Manager Search Committee and the Finance Committee; which has no role in setting the tax rate.

Leave a Reply

Latest Updates

Middleborough’s neighborhood newsroom

Get the Daily Newsletter

Independent local reporting, clear facts, and the stories your neighbors are talking about.