Members of the Carver Earth Removal Committee at their Nov. 17 meeting, with the words: Two pits near closeout. A Makepeace request waits.

Two Carver bog pits near closeout with much of their permitted yardage never dug, as a Makepeace request waits on a site visit

Carver · Earth Removal Committee

In a 23-minute meeting Tuesday, the committee heard that two cranberry-bog excavations are nearly done, held off on an A.D. Makepeace closeout added to the agenda the day before, and again continued a Wareham Street hearing that has waited since May for engineered plans.

John Barrella – The G.O.A.T. News · Nov. 21, 2026

Members of the Carver Earth Removal Committee seated at a long table with papers in Room 4 of Carver Town Hall.
Members of the Carver Earth Removal Committee go over site-visit reports at their Nov. 17 meeting in Room 4 of Town Hall. Still from the Area 58 recording.

CARVER — Two cranberry-bog excavations that the town allowed to remove a combined 520,000 cubic yards of sand and gravel are winding down with about 283,000 of those yards never dug, Carver’s Earth Removal Committee heard Tuesday.

The committee met for 23 minutes in Room 4 of Town Hall on Nov. 17, according to the Area 58 recording. It moved its next meeting to Dec. 15 at 3 p.m., a week later than the date on its agenda, because one member could not make Dec. 8.

At Great Cedar Cranberry, 0 Tremont St., a permit that began in December 2019 allowed 400,000 cubic yards. The operator has removed 152,608, leaving 247,392, Chair Scott Hannula said, reading from the committee’s tracking sheet. He said there had been no digging there for at least a year, and that the state’s permit extension had given the owners time to decide whether to keep going. They did not.

Members who walked the site Nov. 14 said the operator told them the excavation and the tail-water recovery work were finished. Member Judy Richards said the operator reported it had not needed water from Dunham Pond for harvest this year and now has a pump house at the water’s edge. The committee still needs an as-built plan, a pit-closure form and truck-count sheets the operator has not turned in, she said.

The agenda listed the parcel as Map 131, Lot 25. Richards caught the difference at the table, and the committee went with its tracking sheet: Map 122, Lot 25. That is the parcel where the Planning Board approved the Dunham Pond Solar array, with battery storage, on June 23, The G.O.A.T. reported in October.

Behind Plymouth Street, Permit 102 for the Weston bog began in December 2021 with 120,000 cubic yards approved. The operator has used 84,056.44, leaving 35,943, Hannula said. The owner was not at the Nov. 14 walk but let members on the land. Members said loam, gravel and sand piles remain and a seeded slope has not taken, and Richards said the committee should go back in the spring. Hannula said the owner told him he would file a pit-closure form and an as-built “in the coming months.”

Bar chart: Great Cedar Cranberry, 152,608 of 400,000 approved cubic yards removed (38 percent); Weston, 84,056 of 120,000 removed (70 percent).
Approved and removed yardage for the two pits, as read at the meeting. Graphic by The G.O.A.T. News.

Hannula asked the committee’s administrative assistant, Jen Mueller, to press both operators for missing truck counts. Agent Robert Pike told the committee both sites are ready to close.

A Makepeace request, added the day before

A revised agenda, posted Nov. 16, added a closeout for A.D. Makepeace’s Permit 97 on Hammond Street (Map 131, Lots 1-3), which was not on the original agenda. Hannula said the maps and as-built arrived late, that he had not reviewed them, and that he had asked the applicant and landowner not to attend. The committee set a site visit for 8 a.m. Saturday, Nov. 21, starting at the paved entrance at 46 Federal Road, and plans to hear from Makepeace on Dec. 15.

Wareham Street, still without plans

The committee continued the hearing on Derek Maksy’s application for 0 Wareham St. (Map 126, Lot 13-0) to Dec. 15, at his request. Hannula said Maksy still had no engineered plan and that he did not know whether Maksy had been before the Conservation Commission.

The hearing opened May 5 on a conceptual plan, according to the minutes. Maksy’s brother and business partner, Bruce Maksy, said they wanted to lower the grade of the Bailey bog closer to the water. On Aug. 11, Maksy said he needed more time because of a lack of engineering, and Vice Chairman Roger Shores Jr. told him the committee needed stamped plans and that he should meet with the Conservation Commission first, the Aug. 11 minutes say. At the same meeting, Katherine Harrelson of the Community Land and Water Coalition said residents she had spoken with wanted the hearing moved to the evening. Shores said he would take it under advisement. It remains a 3 p.m. hearing.

Separately, the Planning Board voted 4-0-1 on Aug. 25 to deny Maksy’s plan to split 40 Wareham St. into four lots, The G.O.A.T. reported.

The public record so far

0 Wareham Street hearing

May 5
Hearing opens on a conceptual plan.
July 7
Continued to Aug. 11 at the applicant’s request.
Aug. 11
Applicant cites lack of engineering. Continued to Sept. 8.
Sept. 8
Agenda notes the applicant asked to continue to October.
Oct. 6
On the agenda again as a continued hearing.
Nov. 17
Continued to Dec. 15 at the applicant’s request.
Dec. 15
Hearing resumes, 3 p.m., Town Hall Room 4.

Sources: committee minutes of May 5, July 7 and Aug. 11; agendas of Sept. 8, Oct. 6 and Nov. 17; the Nov. 17 recording.

Voting record

How the committee voted

Nov. 17, 2026

Approve the Oct. 6 minutes

Passed 6–0–1. Motion: Roger Shores Jr. Second: Judy Richards. Abstained: Steve Ward.

Nov. 17, 2026

Continue the Derek Maksy hearing, 0 Wareham St., to Dec. 15 at 3 p.m., at the applicant’s request

Passed by voice vote. Motion: Shores. Second: Michael Harrison. No one opposed or abstained.

Nov. 17, 2026

Move the next meeting from Dec. 8 to Dec. 15

Set by consensus. No formal vote.

Aug. 11, 2026

Continue the Maksy hearing to Sept. 8

Passed 6–0. Motion: Ward. Second: Michael Wainio.

July 7, 2026

Continue the Maksy hearing to Aug. 11

Passed 6–0. Motion: Ward. Second: Harrison.

May 5, 2026

Open the Maksy hearing

Passed 5–0. Motion: Shores. Second: Harrison.

Nov. 17 votes are from the Area 58 recording; individual votes were by voice. Earlier votes are from the committee’s May 5, July 7 and Aug. 11 minutes.

The committee itself

The committee approved its Oct. 6 minutes Tuesday, 6-0-1, with member Steve Ward abstaining. Its minutes posted online run through Aug. 11; the Sept. 8 and Oct. 6 minutes were not on the town’s Agenda Center as of Saturday.

The town’s committee page lists seven members. Four are listed as Select Board representatives: Michael C. Harrison, Judy Richards, Steve Ward and Patricia Killeen. Shores holds the Cape Cod Cranberry Growers seat, Wainio the Board of Health seat, and Hannula, the chair, is listed as the industry representative. The terms of Hannula and Richards are listed as expiring in 2026.

The town’s earth removal bylaw, Chapter 136 of the town code, calls for a different mix: three Select Board representatives, two members chosen from the cranberry growers’ association’s nominees, one Board of Health nominee and one trucking-industry member nominated by the committee itself. The town administrator appoints the four members who are not Select Board representatives, and the Select Board endorses them. As listed, the roster has one more Select Board representative and one fewer growers’ representative than the bylaw provides. The website does not explain the difference. The committee page also quotes an older version of the bylaw, which filled the last seat with an earth-removal contractor or construction-industry member.

Who sits on the committee

Carver Earth Removal Committee

Scott Hannula
Chair. Industry representative. Term expires 2026.
Michael C. Harrison
Select Board representative. Term expires 2029.
Judy Richards
Select Board representative. Term expires 2026.
Roger Shores Jr.
Cape Cod Cranberry Growers representative. Term expires 2029.
Steve Ward
Select Board representative. Term expires 2028.
Michael Wainio
Board of Health representative. Term expires 2028.
Patricia Killeen
Select Board representative. Term expires 2029.

Seats and terms as listed on the town’s committee page. The bylaw calls for three Select Board representatives, two growers’ nominees, one Board of Health nominee and one trucking-industry member.

The G.O.A.T. reported in September that the committee has long been led and staffed by people who grow cranberries, mine sand or haul it, including its chair.

Barrella owns and publishes The G.O.A.T. News. He serves on the Middleborough Finance Committee and the Middleborough Town Manager Search Committee. Neither body has a role in the Carver matters in this story.

Leave a Reply

Latest Updates

Middleborough’s neighborhood newsroom

Get the Daily Newsletter

Independent local reporting, clear facts, and the stories your neighbors are talking about.